Book Review: Surviving Death: A Journalist Investigates Evidence for an Afterlife (2017). Leslie Kean.

It was an odd coincidence to me that Leslie Kean, the New York Times award-winning journalist whose book UFOs I previously reviewed, has also written a book on the other “mysteries of life” topic I have found most challenging to my otherwise rational and scientific view of life. That subject has to do with the question of whether our consciousness may survive in some form and transcend our mortal bodies and lifetimes.

As regular readers of this blog know, there are widely known and well-documented cases of very young children who appear to have detailed knowledge of recent individual past lives which are not easily explainable through rational means, and where fraud or trickery do not seem to be likely explanations.

Kean’s book begins with summaries of a few of the best-known of those cases, and the history of academic and scientific research into this strange phenomenon (prominently led by Dr. Ian Stevenson and then Dr. Jim Tucker at the University of Virginia Medical School). She then moves on to evaluate research into several other related types of "near death" and "beyond death" experiences, both contemporary and historical.

In the course of exploring academic research into other categories of reported “beyond death” phenomena, such as near death experiences (NDEs), apparitions, and mediums, Kean regularly probes the quality and meaning of the reports, the reporters and the data. She also regularly raises and considers the possibility of psychic communications between living people (rather than between the living and the dead) as an alternative explanation for some of the strange events and experiences reported, particularly in cases where subjects report detailed information they shouldn’t have been able to know, which the subjects believed had been conveyed from “beyond life” sources or experiences.   

It's a very intriguing and often hair-curling inquiry. She started to lose me in the later chapters, where it seemed she might be starting to move too much into the realm of New Age belief, especially as she began sharing some of her own personal experiences, which often seemed lacking in verifiable evidence, and which she relates with less of the apparent level of skepticism and critical analysis she typically displays toward paranormal topics in her writing.

I’m always on the lookout for that, because being open to the possibility of paranormal phenomena can easily lead one down some bizarre and perhaps absurd rabbit holes. But there was still much to ponder, and much of interest in this very unusual book.

This world and our existence in it may yet be stranger than they appear. Or then again, perhaps not.  But the essential mystery of our being, where we came from, and where if anywhere our consciousness might go when we depart, make it almost obligatory for many of us to speculate about it, and see if there is more to know.  This book is an interesting and reasonably rational exploration of recent academic research and literature on reported phenomena related to this most universal set of human questions. Recommended.